Discover the best cooling aftershaves to soothe razor burn, reduce redness, and refresh your skin. Expert-tested picks for sensitive skin.
Shaving is an essential grooming ritual for millions of men, but it often comes with uncomfortable side effects such as razor burn, redness, tightness, and that unpleasant post-shave heat. This is where aftershaves with a cooling effect truly shine. A high-quality cooling aftershave doesn’t just smell good—it actively soothes irritated skin, reduces inflammation, and restores balance after the blade has done its work.
In this expert guide, we review the best aftershaves with cooling effect available today, explain how they work, and help you choose the right formula for your skin type. Whether you shave daily, have sensitive skin, or live in a hot climate, this article will help you find the perfect post-shave solution.
What Is a Cooling Aftershave?
A cooling aftershave is a post-shave product designed to calm and refresh the skin while delivering a noticeable cooling sensation. This effect usually comes from ingredients like menthol, eucalyptus, witch hazel, aloe vera, or peppermint oil.
How Cooling Aftershaves Work
-
Vasoconstriction: Cooling ingredients constrict blood vessels, reducing redness and swelling.
-
Anti-inflammatory action: Natural extracts calm irritation and razor burn.
-
Temperature regulation: The cooling sensation counteracts the heat caused by shaving friction.
Unlike old-school alcohol-heavy splashes that sting and dry the skin, modern cooling aftershaves are formulated to balance freshness with skin care.
Benefits of Using a Cooling Aftershave
Using one of the best aftershaves with cooling effect provides multiple benefits beyond just fragrance:
-
Instantly soothes razor burn and irritation
-
Reduces redness and post-shave inflammation
-
Refreshes and energizes the skin
-
Helps prevent ingrown hairs
-
Ideal for hot weather and humid climates
-
Leaves skin feeling clean, smooth, and balanced
For men with oily or sensitive skin, cooling aftershaves are often a game-changer.
Best Aftershaves with Cooling Effect – Expert Picks
Below are our expert-reviewed selections, tested and evaluated based on ingredients, cooling intensity, skin compatibility, and overall performance.
1. Proraso Aftershave Lotion (Eucalyptus & Menthol)
Cooling Level: ❄️❄️❄️❄️
Best For: Normal to oily skin
Proraso is a legendary Italian grooming brand trusted by barbers for decades. Their Eucalyptus & Menthol Aftershave Lotion is one of the most iconic cooling aftershaves ever made. From the moment it touches your skin, you feel a refreshing menthol kick that instantly calms razor burn and post-shave heat.
The eucalyptus oil purifies and tones the skin, while menthol provides a clean, long-lasting cooling sensation without excessive dryness. Unlike harsh alcohol splashes, Proraso balances freshness with skin comfort, making it suitable for daily use.
Pros:
-
Strong, satisfying cooling effect
-
Classic barbershop scent
-
Excellent value for money
Cons:
-
May feel too cooling for very sensitive skin
Expert Verdict:
A timeless classic and one of the best cooling aftershaves for men who love a traditional grooming experience.
2. NIVEA Men Sensitive Cooling Aftershave Balm
Cooling Level: ❄️❄️❄️
Best For: Sensitive skin
If you struggle with irritation, redness, or burning after shaving, NIVEA Men Sensitive Cooling Aftershave Balm is a top-tier choice. This alcohol-free formula uses chamomile and witch hazel to calm the skin while delivering a gentle cooling sensation.
Unlike strong menthol-based splashes, this balm focuses on comfort and hydration. It absorbs quickly, leaves no greasy residue, and significantly reduces post-shave tightness.
Pros:
-
Alcohol-free and dermatologist-tested
-
Excellent for sensitive skin
-
Affordable and widely available
Cons:
-
Cooling effect is mild
Expert Verdict:
One of the safest and most reliable cooling aftershaves for men with sensitive or reactive skin.
3. Baxter of California After Shave Tonic
Cooling Level: ❄️❄️❄️❄️
Best For: Premium grooming enthusiasts
Baxter of California is known for blending performance with luxury. Their After Shave Tonic delivers a refined cooling experience using aloe vera, menthol, and witch hazel.
This tonic hydrates, tones, and refreshes the skin without overpowering fragrance. The cooling sensation feels clean and controlled, making it ideal for men who want freshness without harshness.
Pros:
-
Premium ingredients
-
Lightweight, non-greasy formula
-
Subtle, masculine scent
Cons:
-
Higher price point
Expert Verdict:
A premium cooling aftershave for men who value skincare-quality grooming products.
4. Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel
Cooling Level: ❄️❄️❄️❄️❄️
Best For: Razor burn & frequent shavers
The Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel is one of the most effective solutions for men who shave often or suffer from severe razor burn. This gel combines menthol, aloe vera, and blue algae extract to deliver immediate relief and long-term skin repair.
The cooling sensation is strong but controlled, and the gel texture absorbs quickly without clogging pores. It’s especially effective for preventing ingrown hairs and calming irritated skin.
Pros:
-
Maximum cooling relief
-
Excellent for daily shaving
-
Professional-grade skincare formula
Cons:
-
Premium pricing
Expert Verdict:
The best choice for men who need serious post-shave cooling and skin recovery.
5. Brickell Men’s Instant Relief Aftershave
Cooling Level: ❄️❄️❄️
Best For: Natural & organic skincare lovers
Brickell focuses on natural, clean grooming solutions, and their Instant Relief Aftershave is no exception. Formulated with organic aloe vera, witch hazel, and vitamin E, it provides a refreshing cooling effect without synthetic fragrances.
The result is calm, balanced skin with reduced redness and irritation—perfect for men who prefer gentle, natural grooming products.
Pros:
-
Natural and organic ingredients
-
Alcohol-free
-
Fast-absorbing and non-greasy
Cons:
-
Cooling effect is moderate
Expert Verdict:
An excellent natural alternative among the best aftershaves with cooling effect.
How to Choose the Best Cooling Aftershave for Your Skin Type
For Sensitive Skin
-
Choose alcohol-free balms or gels
-
Look for chamomile, aloe vera, and allantoin
-
Avoid heavy fragrances
For Oily or Acne-Prone Skin
-
Opt for lightweight lotions or tonics
-
Ingredients like witch hazel and menthol help control oil
For Dry Skin
-
Use cooling balms with moisturizing agents
-
Avoid high alcohol content
Key Ingredients to Look For
-
Menthol: Provides instant cooling and refreshment
-
Aloe Vera: Soothes and hydrates
-
Witch Hazel: Reduces inflammation and tightens pores
-
Vitamin E: Repairs skin barrier
-
Allantoin: Promotes healing
Ingredients to Avoid
-
High concentrations of alcohol
-
Artificial dyes
-
Harsh synthetic fragrances
How to Use Aftershave for Maximum Cooling Effect
-
Rinse your face with cool water after shaving
-
Pat dry gently—don’t rub
-
Apply a small amount of aftershave
-
Massage lightly into the skin
-
Follow with a moisturizer if needed
Used correctly, even a mild cooling aftershave can deliver impressive results.
Cooling Aftershave vs Aftershave Balm – Which Is Better?
| Feature | Cooling Aftershave | Aftershave Balm |
|---|---|---|
| Cooling Sensation | Strong | Moderate |
| Hydration | Medium | High |
| Best For | Hot weather, oily skin | Dry or winter skin |
FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions
Is menthol aftershave safe for sensitive skin?
Yes, but sensitive skin should use low-menthol or balanced formulas.
Can cooling aftershave cause irritation?
Only if overused or if the formula contains harsh alcohol.
Should I use aftershave every time I shave?
Yes, aftershave helps protect and repair the skin after shaving.
Can women use cooling aftershaves?
Absolutely—many women use them for legs or underarms.
Final Verdict – Expert Recommendation
If you want the best aftershaves with cooling effect, your choice should depend on your skin type and shaving habits:
-
Best Overall: Proraso Aftershave Lotion
-
Best for Sensitive Skin: NIVEA Men Sensitive Cooling Balm
-
Best Premium Pick: Baxter of California After Shave Tonic
-
Best Maximum Cooling: Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel
-
Best Natural Option: Brickell Men’s Instant Relief Aftershave
A good cooling aftershave is not just a luxury—it’s a critical step in maintaining healthy, irritation-free skin. Invest in the right one, and your post-shave routine will never feel the same again.